Sharon Begley
|
Sep 21, 2007 03:56 AM
Something leaped out at me from my colleague David Gates' provocative review of the upcoming Ken Burns World War II documentary, "The War."
As he wrote, "some affiliates—which didn't seem to mind the obscenely
gruesome Holocaust pictures or the scene where a machine gun blows off
a soldier's head—had a problem with the four uses of cusswords, one of
which is alluded to in the anagrammatic title of episode five, "FUBAR."
(For you youngsters, this was a GI term standing for "F---ed Up Beyond
All Recognition." Perhaps it was a snafu to include that.)
This is not news, of course. Films get in trouble with the motion
picture ratings board for saying the F in FUBAR and snafu, but not for
a high, gruesome body count. You can stop a pleasant dinner cold by
uttering that word, but not by describing in gory detail the latest
atrocity on the battlefront. For insight into the peculiarities of
profanity, I turned to psychologist Steven Pinker's new book, "The
Stuff of Thought."
Why is sex, which at first glance (and, if you're lucky, subsequent
glances) seems like a nice thing, the source of so many taboo words,
including the above? Because "sex has high stakes," Pinker writes,
"including exploitation, disease, illegitimacy, incest, jealousy,
spousal abuse, cuckoldry, . . . and rape." As a result, "plain speaking
about sex"--and what is plainer that using variations on the f-word as
noun, adjective and adverb?--"conveys the attitude that sex is a casual
matter." Society as a whole does not want that conveyed, and if you
think we're beyond that, Pinker counsels, notice that for all our
sexual liberation most of us "still don't copulate in public, swap
spouses at the end of a dinner party, [or] have sex with their siblings
and children." Most people want to keep it that way. Sex-loaded terms
starting with f--- threaten to erode the barriers we erect to behaviors
like the above, so we treat them as taboo. Indeed, this aversion to
casual sex is so embedded in the human psyche that trying to reason
your way around it---surely no form of sex, casual or otherwise, is as
bad as battlefield atrocities?---just doesn't work.
More