Let me say this at the outset: I don’t expect the latest discovery
of a “transitional fossil”—the kind of thing that was once called a
missing link—to change anyone’s mind about evolution. I have gotten too
many letters and emails from creationists and intelligent-design
proponents to have any illusions that something as silly as, you know, data
will persuade them that living things change through time as a result
of random mutation and natural selection. (My favorite contained a
sponge with a verse from the bible printed on it; the letter writer
promised to pray for my immortal, if misguided, soul.)
With that preamble, it’s still worth noting what scientists are
reporting in the journal Nature, for it’s a transitional fossil between transitional
fossils. That is, the fish-like thing whose 365-year-old fossil was
discovered by Per Ahlberg of Uppsala University in Sweden and
colleagues in Latvia seems to lie half-way between the lobe-finned fish
Tiktaalik (itself a
transitional fossil between true fish and four-legged land animals) and
primitive tetrapods such as Acanthostega and Ichthyostega.
The new fossil, of Ventastega curonica, is remarkably well
preserved, allowing the scientists to scrutinize it from skull to
pelvis. Its lower jaw resembles a tetrapod’s, while its fangs are more
fish-like.
There was a time when those who rejected evolution asked where the
transitional fossils were, but as more and more are discovered they’ve
changed their tune (if my mail is any indication). According to one, he
won’t believe in evolution until there are “billions” of transitional
fossils. We’ll get back to you on that.