Even when
they were first discovered, in 2005, the four graves near Eulau,
Germany, made scientists sit up and take notice: at 4,600 years old,
they were unusually ancient and well preserved. But now, having
performed genetic and isotopic tests on the remains, scientists have
realized they have something even more momentous: one group of adults
and children buried facing each other is the oldest nuclear family
identified with molecular genetic evidence, Australian scientists are reporting today in the online edition of Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. And
analyses of strontium isotopes in tooth enamel, which reveal where
people came from, indicate that the males and children came from around
the area where they died, while females came from far away: in this
Late Stone Age society, it seems, males found mates from outside the
clan and brought them home, the first evidence of a practice that was
to become widespread during human prehistory.
This region
of Germany is already known in archaeological circles as the discovery
site of the Nebra sky disk, a Bronze Age (1600 B.C.) disc that suggests
that these ancient Europeans knew a little astronomy . Four graves were discovered in 2005: one with a
woman (35–50 years old at death), a man (40–60), and two children (4 to
5 and 8 to 9); a second grave with a woman (30–38) and three children
(an infant, a 4-to-5 year old, and 7-to-9-year old); a third with a man
(25–40) and two children (4 to 5 and 5 to 6), and the final grave with
a woman (25 to 35) and a child (4 to 5).
“Intriguingly,”
write the scientists, “the arrangement of the dead seems to mirror
their relations in life. The latter is reflected by the face-to-face
arrangement of several pairs of individuals and the positioning of
their arms and hands, which are interlinked,” suggesting that the dead
in each grave constituted a family of some kind. In addition, each
grave contained funerary offerings: stone axes for the men and boys,
flint tools or animal tooth pendants for the women and girls, and
butchered animal bones in each of four graves, reportscientists led by Wolfgang Haak of the Australian Centre for Ancient DNA at the University of Adelaide.
And how did they die, and come to be interred together? The radiocarbon
dates for the four graves are identical, the scientists note, strongly
suggesting that all four occurred at the same time. A strong clue to
what happened is the age of the dead: children no older than 10 and
adults 30 or older, but no adolescents or young adults. In addition,
five of the dead were victims of violence: a stone projectile point is
embedded in a vertebra of one, two others have skull fractures, two men
have defensive injuries on the forearm—all of which paints a picture of
a violent raid by a rival clan that killed all 13 individuals, conclude
the scientists, and the survivors--probably young people old enough to
go out hunting or gathering—to bury the dead.
Genetic
analysis of the ancient DNA shows that the man, woman and two children
facing each other were a nuclear family (the woman is the children’s
biological mother, the man, their father). The two children in the
second grave are siblings or half-siblings (they had the same mother),
but the woman buried with them was not she (she was, instead, either a
paternal aunt or perhaps a step-mother). What is remarkable is that the
survivors recognized the primacy of the nuclear family, choosing to
keep it intact in death as in life.