We've
long been fans of the site The Smoking Gun, with its troves of mug
shots, celebrity riders and other documents of the famous and infamous
behaving badly. So it might seem a bit strange for us to accuse these
purveyors of sensationalism of being, well, sensationalistic, but
that's what we're going to do. A few minutes ago, while scanning the
list of stories on The Drudge Report, we came across the following
headline "Online shooting game lets kids target presidential
candidates..." Intrigued, we clicked on the link, which brought us to
The Smoking Gun and the headline "Hey Kids, Shoot Your Favorite Candidate!
Clinton, Obama pace gunners in "Presidential Paintball" online game." The site went on to describe the game as follows:
For
the aspiring young assassin, a popular online games site offers kids
the opportunity to assume the identity of a leading presidential
contender and then shoot their political opponents in a series of armed
confrontations in the White House. While the ammo is paintball, the
game on the hugely popular miniclip.com site allows kids to train a
rifle scope on six presidential aspirants and squeeze off a hail of
shots (which are accompanied with a rat-a-tat sound). The game,
"Presidential Paintball," features six candidates in the crosshairs:
Barack Obama; Hillary Clinton; John Edwards; Mitt Romney; John McCain;
and Rudy Giuliani (it seems the game was developed before the ascension
of Mike Huckabee). If a candidate wins a head-to-head confrontation,
he/she advances to a new shootout, which occurs in various White House
settings, including outside the Oval Office. When a candidate gets
blown away, bloodlessly, a screen appears noting that they have been
"eliminated," not killed. To better direct a fusillade, young gunmen
can use their computer's mouse to place a crosshairs on a candidate's
head or body. Of course, the imagery of Obama and Clinton, both of whom
have been the target of threats and receive Secret Service protection,
being targeted in such a manner-by children, no less-might be seen as
troubling in some quarters.
Sounds disgusting,
doesn't it? Well, we clicked on the link for Presidential Paintball, selected Barack Obama--the candidate and the Level Up staff are both fans of Omar Little on
"The Wire," so perhaps our mutual gangsta might give us an edge--and
fired up the game. For the record, we got past Clinton, Edwards and Giuliani, but we were no match for the perfectly coiffed Romney. And far from the demonic blend of Stephen Sondheim's
"Assassins" and Traffic Games' JFK: Reloaded, what we found was a cartoonish knockoff of any number of Flash-based 2-D shooters
that was more silly than troubling--and would hardly be likely to inspire any "aspiring young assassins."
What
we have here is a failure to communicate. It's that age-old generation
gap between how people of a certain age perceive games--they're all just
for kids--and how people who grew up on games understand them as relevant entertainment for a wide range of audiences. Miniclip has
games for all ages of players, and while there's no blood or gore that
would require them to wall off Presidential Paintball from children, we
seriously doubt that the site was deliberately targeting kids with a weakly satirical game about
presidential candidates playing paintball on the grounds of the White House. The Smoking Gun's description of the game is
technically accurate, yes. But it's cast in such a light as to best freak out anyone who doesn't "get"
the conventions of games into thinking that the next Jason Bourne Lee Harvey Oswald is training at home right now using Presidential Paintball. Poor taste? Yes. Sic semper tyrannis? Not so much.