Newsweek - National News, World News, Health, Technology, Entertainment and more... | Newsweek.com
SPONSORED BY
Full Post
Posted Wednesday, February 06, 2008 12:51 AM

Poetry v. Prose

Howard Fineman

I'm watching Barack Obama speak in Chicago on election night of Super Tuesday. A year ago I was in Springfield, Illinois, watching him declare his candidacy for president on a frigid, windswept morning. The distance he has come is truly astonishing. "What began as a whisper in Springfield," he just said, "is now a chorus that cannot be deterred, for this campaign IS different."

When it comes down to it, the difference between Obama and Sen. Hillary Clinton is less about specifics-though they matter-than about emotion, language, tone and approach. His is a summoning to a higher cause in the name of history, using the cadence of poetry and the pulpit. Hillary, by contrast, is all about three-point plans and legislative language in the service of what they call "constituent service."

Obama calls his campaign a movement. He says we need to get over our fear. The subtext is: I am change, go for it. He talks about what people can do-do for themselves-rather than what government can do.

Advertisement

Both are valid arguments for Democrats. It is a close race, between poetry and prose. The conversation continues.

You must be a registered user to comment.  Click here to register.  Already a user?  Click here to login.

Member Comments

Posted By: mabuhay (February 7, 2008 at 12:07 PM)

The arrogance of Obama will be his undoing.  He has the audacity to say that he could get the support of Clinton supporters, but that Mrs. Clinton cannot count on his supporters.  I doubt that very much.

The media has time and again showed its bias and sexism.  Obama does not get the kind of scrutiny that Clinton gets.  Wake up, MEDIA!  Stop getting lulled by his soaring rhetorics; devote more time on his record or lack of it!


Posted By: PHD for HILLARY (February 7, 2008 at 3:08 AM)

He does not write his own speeches, a white 26 year old guy from Massachussetts. It's nothing but smoke and mirrors. You'll look foolish after this election is over.


Posted By: "Martin Edwin "Mick" Andersen (February 7, 2008 at 12:06 AM)

The news about Hillary Clinton donating $5 million of her own money to her presidential bid struck me as odd.

How was it that someone of once modest means who claimed to have worked tirelessly for 35 years ("fighting for YOU!") in the notoriously badly-paid public interest sector had become so wealthy?

Sure there's been some financial scandals.

And as the late Sen. Everett Dirksen used to say, "A million here, a million there" it adds up to real money."

But why focus on the negative?

Then, suddenly, a tune entered my head and I thought, maybe if I offered a tailored version of it to the Clinton campaign, they'd use it to replace that awful Celine Dion song that used to be Hillary's campaign anthem.

And maybe they'd give me some of that moolah.

I promise I wouldn't ask what account at Clintons, Inc. it came from, or which lobbyist forked it over.

(I'm sure it was in a gesture of sheer generosity--why think evil of people, K Street lawyers have hearts too, no? Wasn't it those nice medical insurance lobbyists who hired that couple, Harry and Louise?)

If you ask me, it's like Bill with that race coding thing. How unfair the criticism! (And how slick he was ;) )

Always leave just a little wiggle room, small enough to fit the word "is" through. Or maybe a cigar. ...

Anyway, remember that girls" song, "It"s My Party," written by Wally Gold, John Gluck and Herb Weiner and recorded by Lesley Gore?

Well how about this version for HRC?

IT'S MY (DEMOCRATIC) PARTY

Nobody knows where my Bill has gone

Monica (Gennifer/Kathleen/Paula/etc.) left the same time

Why was he holding her/their hand(s)

When he's supposed to be mine?

It's my Democratic Party, and I'll cry if I want to

Cry if I want to, cry if I want to

You would cry too if it happened to you

Playin' my constituents, flip-flopping like a Wallenda,

Leave me alone for a while

'Till Bill's dancin' with me

I've got no reason to smile

It's my Democratic Party, and I'll cry if I want to ...