Cutting edge greenhouse technology in the Netherlands could mean
trouble for Kenya's flower industry. Kenyans have long considered
themselves to have an environmental advantage over Europe. Although
they rely heavily on air transport—which leaves a hefty carbon
footprint—Kenya's climate allows it to grow its plants outside as
opposed to indoors, where temperature and light must be controlled
artificially. But a new study from the Hague-based Agricultural
Economics Research Institute (LEI) shows that difference in carbon
dioxide emitted in the production of Kenyan and Dutch roses is smaller
than previously thought. And the gap is quickly closing as the
Netherlands switches to new, non-polluting methods to heat its
greenhouses.
The Netherlands horticultural sector aims to become climate neutral
by 2020. Its new heating technology, currently under trial, involves
capturing energy with solar panels during summer and storing it in
water inside permeable rock materials 120 meters under ground. The
warmed water then gets pumped up to the greenhouse during the winter
months while cold water is circulated in the summer. The first
greenhouse to use this system opened in Holland last year and further
trials are going on in the country right now. At a time when the world
is increasingly conscious of the carbon footprint left by shipping
commercial goods around the globe--most often calculated as "food
miles"--such development could make a big difference to buyers.
If flower consumers do start favoring Dutch suppliers, it would deal
a huge blow to Kenya, which sees the 700 million it earns in exports of
flowers, vegetables and fruit annually as critical to the health of its
economy. Kenya is currently the leading flower exporter to the European
Union, supplying 38 percent of all imported flowers sold there. LEI
claims that previous reports that emissions from Kenyan flowers,
including airfreight, were nearly six times lower than Dutch flowers
are just wrong—partially because they neglected to take into account
variations in flower weight between Kenyan and Dutch varieties. No
doubt Kenyan officials will dispute this new study, which has yet to be
published in full, and continue to resist the introduction of carbon
labeling on all imported flowers. But everyone will have to agree that
what matters most these days is not what you call a rose. It's the
carbon it costs to get there.