Newsweek - National News, World News, Health, Technology, Entertainment and more... - Newsweek.com

Why It Matters

SPONSORED BY
Full Post
Posted Friday, April 18, 2008 5:48 PM

Kenya, Where It Pays to be a Politician

Newsweek

By Andrew Ehrenkranz

Thursday’s swearing in of a broad coalition Cabinet  seems have ushered in  a new era of peace in Kenya. While relief and in some cases, jubilation, is palpable on the streets  of Nairobi today, there’s also a growing dread at sticker shock of this new government of "unity". With opposition leader Raila Odinga as Kenya’s 2nd post-independence Prime Minster, the new Cabinet is the country’s largest ever, at 40 Kenyan cabinet ministers and 52 assistant ministers,  and will cost   Kenyan taxpayers  nearly  $800 million dollars more than last year's government, a huge burden  for average Kenyans already struggling to  make ends meet after months of unrest.

Kenyan politicians are not just among the highest paid in Africa, but around the world, says Tiberius Barasa, a research fellow at Nairobi’s Institute of Policy Analysis and Research .  In a country where the average salary is less than $400 US dollars per year, a Kenyan Cabinet minister makes $18,000 per month,  plus thousands more in allowances and a host of other perks like country homes, club membership, and two new cars.  Earning approximately $216,000 annually (of which only $3,000 is taxable income), Kenyan Cabinet members  make more than their counterparts  in the United States. Kenyan President Mwai Kibaki earns $615,000 US dollars a year, tax-free, far more than that of British Prime Minister Gordon Brown (about $373,000 ) or President George W. Bush($400,000).    “The salaries are actually nearing the level of  comparable politicians  in Italy, currently the  highest in the world. “Barasa says.  Though the original argument had been that higher government salaries prevent corruption,  there’s little evidence to support that justification in Kenya, where a number of high profile corruption scandals have been unearthed over the past few years. A movement amongst civil society groups for a re-adjustment of the pay scale of politicians was thwarted last year, unsurprisingly voted down by the politicians themselves when it came to vote in Kenyan parliament.  At this current moment in Kenya, with a severely hobbled economy after months of unrest and where  more than 300,000  displaced Kenyans still  languish in internal displacement camps,   it remains to be seen if a bigger government will yield results. “Kenya is  struggling to move up the ladder of industrialized nations, we can’t afford to sustain such high salaries.”

Advertisement

For poorer Kenyans, the high salaries are a source of rage. “How can ministers get 1 million(shillings) a month when I am lucky to get a dollar a day?," complains 25 year old Ryan idling near a fly-blown fish-fry in the slum of Kibera. “It’s just greed, they don’t hear us!”  Kibera, a 30-minute walk from downtown Nairobi, has calmed down after the violence that wracked Kenya in the wake of last December's disputed poll. There's even a cautious optimism. "This government is better than no government," says Abdul Fakir, one of a group perching on milk crates in the Makina section. But Fakir is hardly overwhelmed by the new political deal.  "We have faith but more in ourselves than with this government. We have hope for [new Prime Minister Raila Odinga], but we'll see..."

You must be a registered user to comment.  Click here to register.  Already a user?  Click here to login.

Member Comments

Posted By: Mzalendo (May 22, 2008 at 3:12 PM)

I think that Toni is correct in that, worse will befall Kenya if the 'government' continues on the path they are heading, Mass inequalities, insecurity, unemployment, high cost of living, overpopulation and a large %age of the poulation being the youth will only lead to more struggle for necessities, hence more conflict. This in itself then gets channelled by our corrupt and irresposible 'leaders' in to ethnic conflict. As with South Africa, it's always easier to blame the 'other' for your woes rather than directing them to your elected officials who have failed you time and time again.

Their terrible policies and seeming lack of foresight has continued to destroy our country. From the economy, to our national fabric, alll we get is empty promises as they get rich off of us.

We need to hold them accountable and punish them when they err.

Finally Chris: Kibaki stole the election - shamelessly. He got over 80% of his votes from one tribe (the Kikuyu, Embu, Meru).

I THOUGHT THOSE WERE 3 TRIBES? Additionally, so what? Are they not Kenyans too? Seeing as it were Raila's platform was mainly anti-Kikuyu, is it any wonder that a majority of Kikuyu's voted for him?

At least Kibaki produced results in the 5 years he was president, what has Raila done?

His tenure as Roads minister was marked by demolishing houses not building roads. Nobody expected him to build them from his own pocket, maybe he should have used some of those bulldozers to work on the roads before demolishing houses.


Posted By: Toni Kamau (April 20, 2008 at 1:36 AM)

Yes, I do not live in Kenya now. Therefore its easier for me to see a grim and unfirtunately a painful future. I agree with the comments  expressed below. But I still insist. More hyenas also need more to scavenge on...


Posted By: chris_cirulis (April 19, 2008 at 2:36 PM)

Prior comment by Toni Kamau  sounds like one made by someone who is not living in Kenya and therefore insulated from the terrible downside of ethnic conflict. Will they go and fight in that war they feel is postponed for too long?

Kibaki stole the election - shamelessly. He got over 80% of his votes from one tribe (the Kikuyu, Embu, Meru). He watched while Kenyans slaughtered each other. Continues to watch while Mungiki ravages our city. And Mr. Toni Kamau wants to talk about the "state of roads" in Kenya. Has Toni been to Kenya lately. The roads are wrose now (under Michuki). Did he expect Raila to fund road repair out of his pocket? Get real