When John McCain arrives this afternoon for a town hall at
Nashville's Ryman Auditorium, he'll do the usual: give a little speech,
take a few questions, joke that he's "older than dirt" and accuse
Barack Obama of wanting to give Iran's Mahmoud Ahmedinejad a back rub.
But seeing Nashville is Music City and the Ryman is the original home
of the Grand Ole Opry, he'll also have a little surprise up his suit
sleeve, according to Politico's Jonathan Martin: a musical performance by John Rich. As in, one half of the country duo Big & Rich--the people responsible for the song "Save a Horse (Ride a Cowboy)."
For
most general-election presidential candidates, such a setup wouldn't
sound particularly weird. But as far as I can tell, Rich's appearance
marks the first time this cycle that a musical act has opened for John
McCain on the trail. Where's the love?
Neither Obama nor Hillary Clinton has had any difficulty recruiting
rock stars to their cause: so far, Will.i.am, Arcade Fire, the
Decemberists, the Grateful Dead, Macy Gray and Wilco have serenaded
Obama's fans, and Hillary has Ricky Martin, Janet Jackson, Madonna,
Carly Simon, Tony Bennett, Jon Bon Jovi, Melissa Etheridge and Carole
King on board. In contrast, McCain claims but a single prominent
musical supporter: California pop maestro Burt Bacharach.
Unfortunately, a largely Democratic octogenarian composer and one member of an unorthodox country duo do not a showstopping GOP concert lineup make. Even worse:
John Mellencamp and ABBA actually blocked McCain from using their songs
at campaign stops.
(On the bright side, McCain's daughter Sidney is a longtime music
exec who has represented the White
Stripes, Grandaddy, Moby, Stereophonics and Spritualized. So if anyone can hook him up, she can, right? Not so fast: even Sid's a Democrat. Figures.)
Now, it's not like celebrity endorsements translate into votes. In fact, the Annenberg Public Policy Center found
in March that "the endorsement of presidential primary candidates by
notable groups and individuals carries little weight with the public."
But famous musicians can help in other ways--namely by raising money.
In 2004, Bruce Springsteen, who now supports Obama, raked in more than
$10 million for John Kerry with an October swing-state tour, and this
April a pro-Clinton Elton John concert vacuumed up $2.5 million in one
night. Trailing Obama by $144 million in the money race, McCain could use that kind of assistance. Big & Rich? Not big or rich enough.
The problem? He may not get it anytime soon. In 2000 and 2004, the
twangy, evangelical George W. Bush boasted his fair share of backing
bands. But nearly all of them were either Christian (Third Day, Michael
W. Smith), country (Travis Tritt, Larry Gatlin, Billy Ray Cyrus) or
ultra-conservative (Ted "The Motor City Madman" Nugent). A relative
moderate, McCain isn't particularly comfortable with any of those
constituencies--and more importantly, they're not particularly
comfortable with him. What's more, with his musical
tastes formed largely in 1950s, McCain's going to have a tough time
finding favorite acts that are still lively enough to spice up his
rallies--let alone still alive. As the pro-gun Nugent has written, "McCain's advisers had better
figure out how to sing to the conservative base real quickly or he does
not stand a chance at winning." For now, at least, they'll be the only ones doing any singing.