
(AP Photo / Henny Ray Abrams)
Remember what I wrote last week about the McCain campaign pulling back the curtain
and finally allowing the press and the public to interact, however
fleetingly, with its long-sequestered vice-presidential nominee?
Um, nevermind.
Knowing
that Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin is currently visiting Manhattan, Father of
Stumper asked this morning whether I'd be "hanging out" with the
Mooseburger Queen of Wasilla. As we speak, she's over at the United
Nations General Assembly shindig meeting with Afghan President Hamid
Karzai, Colombian President Alvaro Uribe and former Secretary of State
Henry Kissinger in an attempt to establish international insta-cred. I told him no. The sessions are closed to the public, I said, and I'm not planning on joining her press pool.
Turns
out it wouldn't have mattered if I did. Originally, the McCain campaign
indicated that two editorial journalists--Elizabeth Holmes of the Wall
Street Journal and CNN embed Peter Hamby--would be allowed to attend
the so-called “pool sprays” before Palin’s conclaves, which are
basically "glorified photo opportunities during which
journalists can snap photos and film footage and–if they’re lucky–shout
a question or two at Palin and her company before she adjourns
for private meetings," as Ken Vogel writes
over at Politico. But an hour before the events, the McCain campaign
decided to bar both Holmes and Hamby, claiming that the sprays were
appropriate only for photographers and videographers because "there
were not going to be questions or statements." That's one way to put
it. The other? That the campaign would benefit from free pictures of
Palin huddling with world leaders without exposing her to the
possibility of having to hear--not even answer, but hear--a question from a real journalist.
Ultimately, Team McCain allowed CNN to cover the spray for all of 29 seconds--but
only after the cable channel refused to send its cameras. Without CNN
in the room, none of the networks would've received video footage, so
the McCain campaign had to relent. Otherwise, it would've faced a total
TV blackout. As for Holmes, she was out of luck--as was the print pool
relying on her report.
I get that Team McCain wants to
"protect" Palin from the press. But this is getting ridiculous. Last
week, I interpreted Palin's off-the-cuff decision as she was entering a
Cleveland diner to respond to a CBS reporter's request for comment on
the AIG bailout--her first answer to an impromptu question from the
national press since joining the ticket last month--as a sign that
McCain's running mate might be opening up. Instead, it seems to have
marked the start of a new effort to stifle ALL editorial coverage of
the candidate. As the CBS embed reports today,
a Palin staffer told him that questions “weren’t allowed” after he had
the temerity to approach Palin in Cleveland, and the campaign chose not
to notify the pool reporter assigned to be in Palin's motorcade when
the candidate departed Sunday for a scheduled stop at an Orlando
ice-cream parlor--meaning that "there was no editorial presence at the
event."
It's one thing to refuse interview requests, ignore questions, choose rallies over town halls and not even entertain the possibility
of press conferences. That's how Palin has managed to interact with
only one nonpartisan journalist and one group of voters in her four
weeks as a potential vice president. (In contrast, Joe Biden has done more than 80 interviews with local and national media since the Democrats held their national convention late last month.)
But it's another thing altogether to systematically avoid situations
where a question might even be posed, which is what the McCain camp is
doing now. The former is a strategy--an undemocratic strategy, but a
strategy all the same--designed to limit the risk of gaffes. The latter
is pure, irrational fear.
I've said it before
and I'll say it again: The media-bashing masses may squeal with vindictive delight. Still, it's worth noting that the political press corps--as despised as it might be, often fairly--is actually important here. Thanks to Palin's relatively skimpy resume, the
greatest test of her readiness for office--as it was for the
comparably green Obama--will be how well she performs in the campaign
pressure-cooker. There's no better measure of her character and
convictions than dueling with press and the public on a regular basis.
Palin's rise has been remarkable. But until she answers some tough,
fair questions, we won't know whether it's prepared her for high office.
So here's hoping we find out before Nov. 4 whether Crystal City's fear is justified. After that it'll be too late.
UPDATE. 4:50 p.m.: Via Jonathan Martin: "Campaign aides, calculating the cost/benefit analysis of such extreme
measures, have now decided to allow print reporters into Palin's
subsequent meetings this afternoon." He also has Hamby's pool report on Karzai and Holmes' dispatch
on Kissinger, if you're interested. As you can see--no questions--the
McCain camp was being pretty paranoid. I mean, I know reporters are somewhat disheveled-looking, but really...