BOCA
RATON, Fla.--The first drops of rain started falling the moment Barack
Obama arrived, and by the time he started speaking, there was a
downpour. But even inside the B'nai Torah temple it was easy to sense
there was a storm brewing over Boca.
Obama, for one, knew the
forecast. In choosing to visit a conservative synagogue in one of the
country's most densely Jewish congressional districts, the Illinois
senator sought Thursday evening to combat misconceptions about his
background and beliefs within what's proven to be one of his most
skeptical constituencies. Signs of the coming tempest were apparent as
early as January, when Vicki Hercsky, 47, a local teacher, told me after a Rudy Giuliani event a nearby shul that Obama, a Christian, was "Muslim." "He has it
in his blood," she said when I corrected her. "You can't take
away what's given to you. It's given to you for a reason, and that's
who you are. That's who he is." At Boca's Century Village retirement community Wednesday,
local residents greeted voters who'd come to see Hillary Clinton with
banners that said "Obama: Bad for Israel, Bad for America"; they were
back yesterday at B'nai Torah, having transformed the "O" of Obama into
a frowny face. Outside, the Republican Jewish Coalition
distributed a flier--currently doubling as ad in the Palm Beach Post,
the Ft. Lauderdale Sun-Sentinel and the Boca Raton News--that accused
Obama of supporting Arabs over Israelis. And each of the evening's
warm-up speakers--a rabbi, a state senator, a state representative and
a U.S. congressman--pleaded repeatedly with the audience not to believe
the viral email rumors ("Muslim, pro-Palestine, un-American") that have flooded Florida's Jewish community
and have largely come to define the Democratic near-nominee in the ten
months since he last campaigned in the state. "This is salacious and
false and wrong innuendo," said state Rep. Dan Gelber. "Senator Obama
does not have an Israel problem; he is perfect on Israel. The
Republicans have an election problem--and they will only win if you do
not believe your own eyes and your own ears."
Providing
Florida's Jewish voters with that raw material was, of course, was the
point of Thursday's visit. Amid a spate of stories
in recent months about a Hamas spokesman who had spoken kindly of the
candidate, a former pastor, Rev. Jeremiah Wright, Jr., who had made
pro-Palestinian remarks and Obama's own willingness to talk directly
with hostile adversaries like Iran, the campaign has ramped up its
outreach to this small but influential voting bloc by dispatching key
Jewish supporters to upcoming primary states and making the candidate
himself available to the Jewish press. But the B'Nai Torah visit was
unique in that it brought Obama face-to-face with skeptics in a
townhall setting. Aware, perhaps, of the paradox of social psychology
that says that "repeating a claim, even if only to refute it, increases its apparent
truthfulness"--unlike,
say, his opening acts--Obama dismissed the viral smear campaign with a
quick flash of humor. "By the way, if you get an email from a Nigerian
says who you can get a lot of money if you send him $1,000, don’t do
it," he joked. "We don’t believe that stuff when it comes over email.
Why would you believe an email about me?"
Instead, Obama chose
to counter misconceptions largely by reiterating his policy positions:
a 100 percent pro-Israel voting record, according to the American
Israel Public Affairs Committee; no negotiations with Hezbollah or
Hamas, "a terrorist group intent on Israel's destruction"; and demands
that Iran "stop developing nuclear weapons, stop funding terrorists and
stop threatening Israel." "The bottom line is this," he said. "Nobody
can find any statement that I have
ever made that is anything less than unequivocally pro-Israel, that
says Israel's security is paramount." Throughout, the Illinois senator
laced his talking points with personal reminiscences meant to stress
his kinship with the Jewish people, from the sixth-grade camp counselor
whose descriptions of Israel appealed to him as an uprooted, biracial
child--"an outsider in search of a home"--to his 2006 trip to the
Jewish state, where he was struck by "the kindness and resolve of the
people I met." Ultimately, he asked that the audience move past the
"rumor-mongering." "This is part, I think, of the tradition of the
Jewish people is to judge me by what I say and what I have done," he
said. "Don't judge me
because I have a funny name. Don't judge me because I am an African
American... If my policies are wrong, then vote against me because my
policies are
wrong. If I am not honest, if I am not truthful, don't vote for me for
that reason. But don't vote against me because of
who I am--and I know you won't."
Yet the storm clouds lingered even after Obama spoke.
Shortly after the start of an extended question-and-answer session, a
man named Michael Ackerman ("from Brooklyn to Boca") stood up and said
that his daughter, a 26-year-old New York law student, felt Obama had
been "pilloried in the press" and had a question she wanted to ask. "Go
ahead," said Obama. Reading from a computer printout, Ackerman began by
seeming to criticize the media for obsessing over "certain
relationships with controversial people with questionable pasts." But
it soon became clear that was merely a pretense for listing those
"relationships" himself. As Ackerman rattled off his names--a Michigan
imam whom Obama met earlier this month; a Palestinian scholar he knew
from Columbia University--the audience began to boo, and the senator
tried to interrupt.
"All right," said Obama. "I know you're
doing it for your daughter. I've got daughters so I'm sensitive to it.
But I want to make sure I get some other questions
in."
"I'm almost there," Ackerman insisted--then continued with
the names, prompting more jeers. Undeterred, he didn't skip to his
"question" until an elderly man approached and reached for the
microphone. "Ok, ok," he said. "My daughter wants to know, aside form
elected officials, who can you point to as close personal
friends of you and your wife who are solemnly pro-Israel and
anti-terrorist and can say that..."
At this, the audience
erupted, drowning him out. Although Ackerman tried to speak up, Obama
had heard enough. "Let me respond," he said, cutting off his questioner
and quieting the crowd. Admitting that he was "hesitant" to "start
listing out" Jews who could "vouch for me"--"You remember the old
stereotype about someone who says, 'I'm not prejudiced; some of best
friends are Jewish'"--Obama nonetheless mentioned a handful of staffers
(his national finance chair, his Illinois co-chair) who fit the bill,
and noted that "one of the raps on me when I
first ran for Congress in [Chicago's] African American community was
that 'he
was too close to the Jewish community.'" But he was clearly
uncomfortable with Ackerman's insinuation. "To pluck out one person who
I know and who I had a conversation with
and who has different views than nine of my other friends and then to
suggest that shows I'm somehow not sufficiently pro-Israel is, I think,
a very problematic statement," he said. Unfortunately, the discomfort
didn't stop there. A few moments later, a woman who claimed she kept in
touch with Iranian acquaintances from her childhood in India,
"informed" the audience that her "friends" "say they are so excited
because they can’t wait to have another president as good as Jimmy
Carter... who will allow them to do what they want without limits."
Needless to say, Obama, who reiterated his anti-nuke, anti-terrorism
stance toward the Iranian regime, wasn't particularly flattered.
Obama's
so-called Jewish problem is easy to oversstate. Most of the B'nai Torah
crowd was appreciative, and many were adoring; Obama received several
standing ovations. What's more, a Gallup poll last month showed him
clobbering John McCain among Jewish voters 61 percent to 32 percent.
But
it's also worth noting that Gallup had Clinton outperforming the
Illinois senator by five points, and that
John Kerry captured 76 percent of the Jewish vote in 2004. That wasn't
enough to win Florida, a state where Jews account for five percent of
the electorate. Obama's goal, of course, is to improve on Kerry's
finish. Judging by Thursday's initial effort, though, there are still
some rainy days ahead.