NEW YORK--Be careful what you wish for, Senator.
Last night at Manhattan's storied Federal Hall--site,
in 1789, of George Washington's inauguration and the ratification of
the Bill of Rights--John McCain held the first of what would've been 10
joint town hall meetings with Democratic opponent Barack Obama. Except
that Obama, citing logistical conflicts, wasn't there. According to
McCain, flying solo was a shame. "This town hall meeting tonight would
have been a little bit
more interesting if Senator Obama had accepted my request,” he said.
But "interesting" or not, I can't help but think that the Obamaless
event was a blessing in disguise for the presumptive Republican nominee.
The
reason? A pair of brief but telling exchanges near the end of evening.
The first came when a young, blond woman in the back row, maybe 25,
stood up and asked McCain how he
would appeal to her peers--many of them registered Republicans voting
for Obama, she said, because his campaign "speaks their language." In
and of itself, McCain's answer was good--he didn't
seem particularly old, or out-of-touch, or any of the other things
that a septuagenarian's staff might worry about him seeming. He assured
the woman that "there will be a real competition for young people's
votes." He mentioned that he'd appeared on "Saturday Night Live, and
Jon Stewart, and MTV Town
Hall." And he delivered a winning, self-deprecating joke--"The primary
qualification to be president of the United States is to be very, very,
very, very old"--before pivoting to his real reply: I'll treat them like the adults they are. "I've got to communicate that I'll give them a
more prosperous, safer world than the one that I
had," he said--refusing, wisely, to condescend.
But
the thing is, it's easy to dismiss the age issue when you're the only
candidate on stage. Not so easy: dismissing it when you're standing
alongside a rival who leads by as much as 30 points among young voters and represents, as conservative columnist Peggy Noonan puts it, "the New America."
In that scenario, there's a direct comparison between older and younger,
past and future, 71 and 46--in other words, "the kind of direct
comparison that most campaigns strive to
avoid." Alone, he's fine. But side by side with Obama, McCain--whom 30 percent of voters consider too old to be president--can't help but suffer, at least a little, when the conversation turns to age.
McCain's
other challenge: observers tend to see every slip, blip or gaffe
through the prism of his senior citizenship. In late May, for example,
the abrupt, cold-related cancellation of a McCain event in Pennsylvania
spurred frenzied speculation about the senator's health--speculation
that wouldn't have attended a similar announcement from Obama.
Likewise, there's little doubt that Democrats keep describing McCain as
"confused" for a reason. So even though it received no coverage in
today's reports, the exchange that immediately followed the "youth
vote" moment last night might have seemed significant to the chattering
classes had it happened in Obama's presence.
Taking the microphone, an "Hispanic-American" lawyer posed a simple, direct question: "What character traits
are you looking for in the people who will serve [on the Supreme Court] for many, many years
and help shape your legacy?"
McCain's
response was odd--to put it mildly. "I thank you," he said. "As we were
talking about
the youth vote, we're also going to have to compete strongly for the
Hispanic, Latino vote as well, and I believe I can do that." With that,
he trailed off. Of course, the man hadn't asked about McCain's Hispanic
outreach efforts. But what had he asked? Attempting to answer, McCain,
it seemed, was at a loss for words. There were a few awkward "um's"
as he tried to start a sentence. "I believe that, um..."
But when the senator realized it wasn't going anywhere, he did what any
competent conversationalist does in a similar situation: turn the
question back on the questioner. "Could you tell me a little bit more
about your
background that indicates this concern?" he said, vaguely. "Just a bit
more."
On
the trail, McCain often requests more information from a voter
who's asked about a personal issue like, say, health care. But in this
case it was unclear what bearing the man's background had on the topic
at hand--that is, Supreme Court appointees. It was hard to avoid the conclusion that McCain
couldn't quite recall what was being asked. Luckily, the man--who also
informed the senator that he was a father, a Catholic and a New York
native--quickly rephrased the question, and all was well. "Now I
understand your question better," said McCain, as if it were
incomprehensible until situated in the proper biographical context.
The
point here is not that McCain is, you know, senile. He's not. Everybody
loses their train of thought from time to time--I've done it on
national television--and everybody fumbles a few words. But everybody
catches colds, as well. Whether you think this particular exchange is
relevant, revealing, or completely pointless, it's impossible to
imagine the punditocracy--Chris Matthews, Wolf Blitzer, Charlie Gibson,
et al--comparing a head-to-head Obama-McCain cagematch without making a
big deal about it. And that, for McCain, is the danger of these duels--which, unlike last night's event, will include some non-Republicans in the audience (see video above), and thus much more contentious questions.
In
the end, however, none of this may matter. After receiving a
counterproposal from Obama offering just one town hall and one extra
debate in response to McCain's suggestion of 10, McCain campaign
manager Rick Davis confessed today that talks seem to have broken down.
"We fear that our negotiations over joint town hall meetings are
turning
into a debate about process," he said. "That is exactly what we have
always hoped to avoid." Unfortunately, it's exactly what Team
Obama--which has apparently concluded that the costs of joint
appearances outweigh the benefits--wanted to happen. In the end, no
town halls is probably good news, in some respects, for both
candidates--even if it's bad news for the rest of us.