Check this space for frequently updated analysis of the Super Tuesday returns.
OVERALL
With wins in Delaware and Connecticut, it was clear that Obama could
capture toss-up states. But in the end, he couldn't win the biggest
battleground of all: California. Combine Obama's defeat there with
losses in Massachusetts and New Jersey--states where some observers
expected his recent surge to counter Clinton's early strength--and
Hillary may wake up Wednesday with a "stopped Obama's
mo" narrative working in her favor.
All in all, though, expect a
tie. "In terms of delegates we're going to end up in essentially a draw
today," Obama guru David Axelrod told reporters earlier. That's not
spin. The current count is Obama at 562 and Clinton
at 582, according to CNN--with neither California (Clinton) or Missouri
(Obama) tipping the scales too far in favor of one candidate, thanks to
proportional allocation of delegates.
On
the
Republican side, McCain, who won the crown jewel of California shortly
after midnight, is still well on his way to steamrolling the
opposition--but perhaps without sizable Southern support, as
Huckabee eked out close victories across Dixie in West Virginia,
Georgia, Tennessee and Alabama. Expect the pundits to obsess over
Huck's surprise showings at the expense of McCain's expected victories,
even if they're not worth as many delegates--an emphasis that will
underscore the work still required to reconstruct the
Republican coalition.
Romney, of course, was waiting for the Big
Enchilada with fingers crossed--he needed a major win outside of
his home states of Massachusetts and Utah to stay alive. But when word finally
arrived that McCain had captured the Golden State, you had to wonder: will
Romney keep on keeping on?
One MSM note going forward: the
networks have spent the night "calling" full states like it's Election
Day--even though, in many cases, the delegate tallies matter more. Not
that I blame them; what else is there to do before the votes are even
counted? Still, I wonder if by the time they get around to
crunching the numbers, viewers will have moved on--or fallen
asleep--with largely irrelevant story lines already firmly fixed in the
national consciousness.
DEMOCRATS
Clinton: Arizona, Arkansas, California, Tennessee, Oklahoma, New York, Massachusetts, New Jersey
Clinton
is looking at least as strong as expected, if not
stronger, considering Obama's wave of positive press over the past two
weeks. The first big disappointment of the night for Obama: New
Jersey. An upset there would've signaled a potential tidal wave
nationally, but the Latino vote swung the state for Clinton--which
ended up also helping the New York senator capture Arizona. The
Clinton camp is breathing a sigh
of relief after fending off a last-minute Obama surge in Massachusetts,
fueled, perhaps, by the Kennedy endorsements. (Some good they did.) The
size and swiftness of the win (a surprise even for the Clintonistas)
was encouraging--especially as an omen for California, where Clinton
was
hoping to thwart a similar Obama insurgency. And ultimately she did,
finally capturing the Golden State as Tuesday turned to Wednesday (key constituencies: Latinos and women). In
the "no duh" category,
Clinton was expected to win handily
in all three Southern states and her home state of New York. Final margins--and the all-important delegate counts,
which could show closer-than-expected Obama finishes in the Empire, Garden, Golden and Bay States--still to come.
Obama: Georgia, Illinois, Delaware, Alabama, North Dakota, Kansas, Idaho, Colorado, Missouri, Alaska
Delaware
was the first toss-up decided tonight, and was seen in Obama circles as
a sign of good things to
come in Connecticut--another state where independents, who tend to
favor Obama, weren't allowed to vote. The harbinger turned out to be
true; Obama soon
made the
Constitution State, once a Clinton lock, the second swing state to
swing his way. And by 1:00 a.m., the Illinois senator completed a
come-from-behind victory in Missouri--a famous political
bellwether--clinching his near sweep of the South and Plains States.
The losses in Massachusetts and California, however, were serious let
downs that prevented Obama from harnessing any real momentum for Feb. 6
and beyond. Interestingly, Obama's massive margins
in Georgia--he won among women and white men, for example--were a bit
unexpected, and helped rebut the insta-CW that the senator took the
Peach State solely on the strength of his (still overwhelming) black
support. A similar story in Alabama, which was a closer contest than Georgia. I expected
North Dakota, Minnesota, Idaho, Colorado, Alaska and Kansas to fall for Obama--they're caucus
states, which means they're well suited to his organizational strengths
(especially among young voters). And as for Utah--Clinton is hugely unpopular in the Beehive State, making it ripe for an Obama rout.
Too Close to Call: New Mexico
REPUBLICANS
McCain: California, Illinois, New Jersey, Delaware, Connecticut, New York, Oklahoma, Arizona, Missouri
No alarms, no surprises. With California and Missouri comfortably in
his column, McCain is crushing his rivals in the
delegate count and will remain the leader when all is said and done.
"As much as I've relished come-from-behind wins," he said tonight, "I
think we have to get used to the idea that we are the Republican party
front-runner for the nomination. And I don't mind it one bit." That
said, McCain had hoped to
show better below the Mason-Dixon line, where social conservatives made
it clear tonight that they're still uncomfortable with candidacy.
Huckabee for VP? It'd be one way to thank him for crippling Romney. Let the healing begin.
Romney: Massachusetts, Utah, North Dakota, Montana, Minnesota, Colorado, Alaska
A
loss in the Bay State would've killed Romney's campaign. Same goes for
Utah, where he
led in the final pre-Feb. 5 polls by 75 percent. Minnesota was a
pleasant surprise (I had it leaning
to McCain). And Romney hit his targets in the low-delegate "frontier"
states, where he was the only candidate to really compete. But with a
bruising psychological defeat in California, his
firewall state, and dispiriting bronzes across the South, it's
difficult to image Mitt continuing (credibly, at least) to cast himself
as the only conservative alternative
to McCain. Unless, of course, he's neck-and-neck with Mac in California
delegates. Unlikely--but it's his last best hope.
Huckabee: West Virginia, Arkansas, Alabama, Georgia, Tennessee
Arkansas was no shocker--it's Huck's home state. But West
Virginia spelled serious trouble for Romney, who was expected to
win. (Read my take here.)
Eventually, with narrow upsets over McCain in Georgia, Tennessee and
Alabama--Mac led narrowly
going in--Huckabee completed a Southern sweep that dashed Romney's
hopes of building an anti-McCain coalition of conservatives. In fact,
now that Romney has lost California, Huck will likely supplant Mitt as
the last non-McCain standing--an amazing feat considering his constant
lack of cash.
"Over the past few days, some people have been saying
that this is a two-man race," he said from Little Rock. "Well,
guess what? It is. And we're still in it." Whether he hangs on as serious
rival or potential veep remains to be seen.
Paul: N/A
No
wins for Paul, but his libertarian leaning message endeared him to
hands-off North Dakotans and Alaskans, who awarded the Texas
congressman a total of 10 delegates. Still, with an overall tally
that's 10 times smaller than Huckabee's, he's no closer to the
nomination tonight than he was this morning.