Jonathan Alter
|
Apr 30, 2007 05:38 PM
From NEWSWEEK's May 7, 2007 issue - Henry Waxman looks like
your accountant, but he acts more like a dog with a bone—the hard bone
of truth. This short, bald, mustached California congressman is digging
up what really happened inside the U.S. government during the early
years of the new century. Last week, for instance, Waxman's House
Committee on Oversight and Government Reform heard startling testimony
about how the Army lied repeatedly to protect its image, covered up
those lies, then lied again. Instead of depressing me, the hearings
left me strangely exhilarated. Historians will likely see the 2006
midterm election returns as indispensable to their work. Without a
change in party control, we would never have a chance to get to the
bottom of what has happened to this country.
Remember
Cpl. Pat Tillman, the patriotic former Arizona Cardinals defensive back
who walked away from a fat NFL contract to join the Army Rangers in
Afghanistan? After Tillman was killed in action in 2004, the Army told
his family and the country that he had died in a heroic struggle with
the enemy. In fact, Tillman was accidentally killed by friendly fire
from American forces. Within hours of his death, the Army went into
damage-control overdrive, posting guards to keep eyewitnesses from
talking, cutting off phone and Internet service to the base and even
burning Tillman's uniform before awarding him the Silver Star. His
brother Kevin, who was serving as a soldier in the same unit, was kept
in the dark. One fellow Ranger testified he was directly ordered to lie
to Kevin about what occurred. At Waxman's hearing, Kevin accused the
military of "intentional falsehoods" and "fraud." An internal Army
probe showed that when Lt. Gen. Philip Kensinger (now retired) said at
a public memorial service that Pat was killed by Taliban forces, he
knew otherwise.
Kevin
Tillman attributes the pack of lies to a desperate need within the Army
to avoid more bad publicity after the Abu Ghraib Prison scandal. But
that implies this was an isolated case. It wasn't. I did a story last
year about a California mother named Nadia McCaffrey who was told that
her son, a California National Guardsman, had died in an enemy ambush.
It took the Army two years to admit that in fact he was shot in the
back by the very Iraqi troops he was training. Such stories have not
caused more outrage because of widespread reluctance to denigrate the
Army. But the instinct to "support the troops" and avoid Vietnam-era
disrespect for the military has left us blind to many abuses.
Read the rest of the column here
More