Newsweek - National News, World News, Health, Technology, Entertainment and more... - Newsweek.com
SPONSORED BY
Full Post
Posted Monday, September 14, 2009 5:01 PM

Most Doctors Like the Public Option

Newsweek

By Jeremy Herb

Ever wondered what your doctor thinks about the public option? A survey published today found most doctors are in favor of it. The study, funded by a grant from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, found nearly three quarters of physicians surveyed supported a public option in the U.S. health-care system. The majority, 63 percent, favored a health-care system with both private and government-run insurance options, and 10 percent preferred a public-only system. Twenty-seven percent favored a private insurance system without creating a public option.

The report, published in The New England Journal of Medicine and written by Salmoeh Keyhani and Alex Federman of the Mount Sinai School of Medicine, surveyed 2,130 physicians between June 25 and Sept. 3. The poll examined support for the public option geographically, too, finding that a majority of physicians in all regions supported it. "The clear message here is that physicians who are on the front line of the health-care system know the system is broken and that it's time for us to do something about it," says John Lumpkins, a senior vice president at the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.

Advertisement

The survey also asked doctors if they supported expanding Medicare to allow 55- to 64-year-olds the option to "buy in." Fifty-eight percent were in favor. The researchers pointed out that although many voters fear that a public option will mean government interference with medical decision making, most doctors themselves aren't particularly worried. "Our data suggests that physicians do not view Medicare, a major U.S. government program, as negatively affecting their autonomy and ability to get their patients the services they need," the authors wrote.

It's not all good news for public option proponents though:  while physicians support Medicare expansion, they still like working with private insurance more. Forty-six percent said their overall experience was better with private insurers, compared to just 21 percent who favored traditional Medicare.

Tag(s):
You must be a registered user to comment.  Click here to register.  Already a user?  Click here to login.

Member Comments

Posted By: sharenews (September 22, 2009 at 11:18 PM)

My question is….why isn’t President Obama & co. looking at an alternative method  (Health Care Choice Act) of addressing needed competition in the Health Care (HC) Insurance company to bring down the massive high cost premiums?  A bipartisan alternative. I hope this act goes somewhere.

All I hear is Pres. O and company shoving his government option agenda for HC down our throats, thus the bubble up of masses of “angry mobs” marching in Washington DC a few weekends ago (just about ignored by the mainstream media) looking for an alternative to growing a big bureaucratic government.

Rep. Kelsey To Introduce Health Care Choice Act

posted September 22, 2009

http://www.chattanoogan.com/articles/article_159397.asp


Posted By: mrdprince (September 16, 2009 at 2:48 PM)

Re: Sharra_R

I think that we both agree that Medicare is abused by padding, extra unneeded services and, as we see in the news many times, outright fraud.  If a person pays for insurance then they expect to get what they pay for.  Those in groups like Medicare and Medicaid are many times those who are unable to pay for anything. They take it or leave it as you say.  That is hardly negotiating power.  More likely than not, they take it.  I don't know, maybe we are looking at a different group of people involved.  Whether private or public options are used, the administration of those options is key to success or failure.  One thing that I have learned in my life is that to every problem there is a solution. . . or at least a way around it.  Sometimes we tend to go around in order to get quick results which are at first good.  In the long run this usually leads to further complications.


Posted By: R.R. (September 16, 2009 at 4:16 AM)

For those of you are against the government spending money and against the government getting involved to help fix this problem:  How much do you think it will cost this nation in health care and in human lives, if you, "let the free market decide" ?    Any economist will tell you that the cost of maintaining the status quo on health care in the U.S. is far, far greater than the government cost for fixing this chronic problem that is getting worse.

Last I checked in every nationwide survey and poll that I've ever seen, a majority of doctors and nurses, as well as the American voting electorate are for the Public Option.  

And based on all the private, Right-Wing blogs I've also read, these voting Republicans oppose the Public Option, because it will raise taxes on the wealthy, and because a black man is sitting in the Oval Office.  

The Right-Wing also say that "helping people" is, "a trait of a bleeding heart liberal," and that, "liberals are socialists," and, "socialists are communist nazis," and "socialist nazis are minions of Satan."  Thus, if you help someone who is sick, or say people should help sick people, you are evil in the wingnut's mind.  

And so they pack loaded assault rifles in their "open carry" ideology, to threaten the lives of 'liberals' in public venues, liberals who are for helping people by promoting health care reform, and so these gun-wielding, Republican wingnuts turn around and say to the police they are only good patriots, exercising their 2nd amendment rights to bear arms. They then go back to their religious-right peers, and say that they're supposedly doing the American public a service by threatening "evil ones" in the crowd.  They see President Obama as a black foreigner with liberal ideas.  

Is it any wonder then, that you have right-wing Christian churches with pastors convincing their congregations to pray for, and help set the stage for the violent and sudden death of the President that they see as, 'a minion of Satan'?  They've already said in their blogs don't want health care reform to come to pass because they see it as a product of a, "liberal evil," and they will do everything in their power to stop it.

Mr. President, I hope you have kevlar underwear and enough Secret Service to guard you, because America has homegrown terrorists on a religious mission.  (FoxNews commentators and Rush Limbaugh of course, defends these armed wingnuts that go around murdering family planning doctors, and not surprisingly, dangerous con-men like Glenn Beck and Bill O'Reilly, calls these people, "true American patriots").