America's
conservatives are probably feeling pretty chuffed today after reading Gallup's recent polling
on political ideology. The data confirm Gallup's
June finding that conservatism is the dominant ideology in the country right
now. About 40 percent of respondents identified themselves as conservative, while 36 percent
called themselves moderate and 20 percent liberal. The last time the conservative
number was so high was in 2003 and 2004. The reason today's numbers are
important is that they've jumped up 3 points after holding steady at 37 percent from
2006 to 2008. Considering the size of the sample and the lack of movement in the past few years, that jump is significant.
Although the numbers don't look great for Democrats, they're
not exactly a reason for popping champagne at the RNC. According to Jeff Jones, managing editor of the Gallup poll, the number of people identifying as
conservative rose similarly when Bill Clinton assumed the presidency in 1993.
In 1992, conservatives made up 36 percent of the electorate. That number popped up to
39 percent in 1993. It dropped back to 38 percent in 1994, when Republicans took control of
Congress, and reached its contemporary nadir—36 percent—the following year.
Although it's enormously difficult to prove a direct
correlation between the change of administration and the increase in
conservatism, Jones told your Gaggler that it's hard not to think that the
changeover prompted voters to shift their positions a little. He says such
ideological changes often come from people who don't pay all that much
attention to politics, or don't have strongly held political convictions. Often
these people like the idea of a middle path, a country that doesn't skew one
way or another. So, when they sense—largely through media coverage—that the
country is moving liberal, they'll adjust their position to try to
promote more moderate policies.
Now, consider where the growth in conservatism is coming
from in Gallup's
latest numbers: independent voters. In 2008, 29 percent of independents called
themselves conservative. Now 35 percent do, while the number identifying themselves as liberal dropped
from 20 percent to 18 percent, and moderate from 46 percent to 43 percent. Meanwhile, the ideological makeup
(liberal/moderate/conservative) of the Democratic and Republican camps was
relatively steady. While it is certainly true that not all independents fall
into the "not paying much attention to politics" category, those people are
more likely to be independent than party-affiliated. They're probably also less
likely to vote.
Perhaps what should worry Democrats more is not an overall
tendency to claim oneself as a conservative, but the shifts of particular
issues. Gallup
reported upticks in the number of people who believe there is too much
government regulation; that gun laws should be less restrictive; that
immigration should be decreased; and that global warming is exaggerated.
Attitudes about gay marriage, Iraq,
and Afghanistan
haven't really changed. For Democrats, this is probably the most worrying
sentence in Gallup's background brief: "There are no major examples of U.S. public opinion becoming more
liberal in the past year." It's that, not a general ideological preference,
that will make the Democratic legislative agenda even more difficult going
forward.