Newsweek - National News, World News, Health, Technology, Entertainment and more... - Newsweek.com

HEADLINE HEADLINE HEADLINE

SPONSORED BY
Full Post
Posted Friday, September 11, 2009 11:11 AM

Introducing the Fit, Fat Gallery: Reflections on the Fat Wars, Part 1

Kate Dailey

A few weeks ago we ran a series called "The Fat Wars" that looked at the way we talk about obesity in this country, and whether our current methods of fighting the war on fat were working. Within the course of the articles, we made a few unsubstantiated remarks about fat people being just as able to run or bike as thin people. (Unsubstantiated because we wrote them as fact, without citing backup evidence.) In doing so,  the article generated lots of comments from people basically calling it bull. This was expected: a point we researched but didn't articulate in the article about why America is so darned angry with fat people is that the anonymity granted by the Internet tends to bring out the worst in people; the points we did articulate argued that fat people are easy targets for rage, which people like expressing, and projected self-loathing, since we all worry about weight. Still, it seemed like what President Obama refers to as "a teachable moment," an excuse to solicit reader participation, and also a chance to do a photo gallery, which are fun and pretty and get lots of clicks. 

With that in mind, we solicited photos of healthy, heavy readers─an exercise that was not without its own controversies. Some fat people were energized by the chance to disprove stereotypes, while others felt like they shouldn't have to prove anything to anyone, nor should they have to strap on climbing gear or a bike helmet to "earn" a little human kindness and respect. (I believe "dancing monkey" was the term one reader of Shapely Prose used when discussing our request). 

Nevertheless, we received a lot of great submissions, and picked some of the best images (and by best, we mostly mean "best photographic quality") for our Happy, Healthy, and Heavy gallery. 

It's amazing, and you should all check it out. We debuted the gallery yesterday to coincide with a Today show segment on the Fat Acceptance movement. The Today bit also provided  an excuse to resurrect some of the older Fat Wars content, along with two new op-eds from two sides of the obesity issue.

Kate Harding, writing on Jezebel, had a LOT to say about those op-eds.  She's not the only one: there are darts and laurels coming in from all sides on this issue. I, in turn have a lot to say as well─both about Harding's points, the counterarguments I've received, and my experiences covering the Fat Acceptance movement and the medical community's response to obesity.

But─and this goes against all principals of blogging, which prizes speed and timeliness and the 24-hour news cycle─it's 9/11 and Caster Semenya is intersex and when I'm not blogging, I'm editing, and there's a lot of that backed up on my e-desk and the trains were slow and it's raining, all of which is to say that I  want to think very clearly and carefully about what it is I'm writing, and to do that I need to take a little more time. (Bad blogger!)

Check back later today or Monday for my extended reflection on our Fat Wars project (and for a great reported piece on the role of intersex athletes in competitive sports).  

In the meantime,  scroll through our gallery Happy, Healthy, and Heavy.

Read Kate Harding's piece on Jezebel. (And feel free to Google around to see what other people are saying, if you're looking to kill a little time on a rainy Friday.)

And if you're so inclined, check out the Today show piece, wherein Matt Lauer exiles me from any future shows (which is apparently a very good sign).

 

You must be a registered user to comment.  Click here to register.  Already a user?  Click here to login.

Member Comments

Posted By: fatgirlsguide (October 5, 2009 at 6:09 PM)

I haven't run across too many people in the fat acceptance camp that dismiss the health concerns associated with being overweight. It's not about being given a free pass or self-delusion, it's about changing the black-and-white thinking about what weight means - to self worth, to capabilities, to social vitality. Smoking causes critical health issues, so does drug and alcohol abuse and whole lot of other behaviors. But you won't see more people getting sneered at, made fun of, discriminated against or made to feel inferior and undeserving than you will in the fat community. Change comes when people learn to respect themselves and their bodies. And while that self-respect needs to ultimately come from within ourselves, it's a long, dark hole to crawl out of when the collective message from the rest of the world is, "you're disgusting!"

I edit The Fat Girl's Guide to Living (fatgirlsguidetoliving.com), and our readers are primarily overweight women who are in various stages of changing their lives, their health, but not willing to sit back and miss out on things like rock climbing, career advancement, kayaking and feeling good about themselves until they hit a magic number on the scale (or on a jeans rack). It, like fat acceptance and the "health at any size" community, supports a broader view of "health" than just calorie counting and a gym membership can tackle.


Posted By: CeliaS (September 22, 2009 at 11:33 PM)

I agree with rioguy - a few photos of fat people on bikes or on horseback doesn't take away from the substantial documented medical evidence that shows that most of the people in those photos are more likely to contract a fat-induced ailment – or perhaps I should use the more politically-correct term ‘lifestyle-related health problem’? - than their thinner counterparts. This gallery proves nothing.


Posted By: MizzSabra (September 14, 2009 at 6:46 PM)

Maybe that person with the handicapped placard became overweight BECAUSE of their disability.  Ever think about that JekelKat?  It happens.  I have a friend who was in a near fatal motorcycle accident, spent 4 months in the hospital and has gained a significant amount of weight because he is unable to exercise due to the injuries and yes, he has a handicapped placard because he has difficulty walking from his injures, not from being fat.