Kate Dailey
|
May 27, 2009 07:08 AM
Those of you who caught me on Public Radio International's The Takeaway earlier this morning may want to take a look at these articles, which discuss the issues surrounding Daniel Hauser and Alexander Draper more in-depth. (Those who missed me live can hear the segment by visiting The Takeaway's website: just click the first link).
Towards the end of the interview, host Faria Chideya asked whether those living in poverty were more likely to be singled out for scrutiny by the Department of Social Services. In the car ride back (thanks, pledge dollars!) I had more time to think about her question, which seemed to ask whether or not there was a certain amount of discrimination against poorer, often African-American families. (The interview experience was kind of like giving birth; I've somehow blocked out most of it. When the broadcast replays around 8.40, I'll be sure to listen to clarify the question and her intent.)
It's true that families living in poverty are more likely to be brought up on charges of medical neglect. But I think that's in large part because these families are more likely to be working with social service organizations already, and therefor "on the radar" when things go wrong. The doctors they visit have significant experience dealing with social services, so are more likely to take steps—and know which steps to take—when it appears a child is being medically neglected.
In my mind, the major discrimination occurs in the resources available for struggling families to care for sick kids: government -provided health care can only do so much if you don't have a reliable means of transportation to get to the doctor's office, especially if the only doctor that will take your government-provided insurance is all the way across town. More importantly, since America is the only wealthy nation that doesn't guarantee any kind of paid sick leave, parents struggling to make ends meet often have to decide between taking their child to the doctors or missing a day's pay, and too many absences - even to take your child for necessary medical care—can lead to termination. It's hard to pay for medicine when you're unemployed.
Having a sick kid is a big job, one that requires time even more than money (since there are social services that can help fund the treatment of children if finances are an issue). And for parents working hard just to stay solvent, time is something they can't afford.