Newsweek - National News, World News, Health, Technology, Entertainment and more... | Newsweek.com

Wealth of Nations

SPONSORED BY
Full Post
Posted Wednesday, November 11, 2009 6:00 AM

Afghans Optimistic Despite U.S. Public Opinion

Newsweek

By Jerry Guo
Since Barack Obama took office, U.S. public opinion has grown increasingly bleak on Afghanistan's prospects. Yet Afghans are increasingly optimistic. In an Asia Foundation survey taken in June and July, 42 percent said the country is moving in the right direction, up from 38 percent last year, despite rampant corruption and Taliban advances. The margin for error was about 4 percent, so this doesn't represent a big spike, but it's still striking that Afghanistan's morale is not decaying as fast as the world's view of Afghanistan is. 

Polls in allied nations including Britain and Germany show declining support for the war effort. "I don't think Afghan public opinion has swung as wildly as U.S. public opinion," says Daniel Markey, a former State Department official who travels frequently to Afghanistan. At the same time, Afghans hold very low expectations for governance and economic progress. Indeed, pollsters could not reach more than 100 villages, primarily in the south, the Taliban's stronghold. Those living in interior war zones may be just as demoralized as Westerners, but probably not. Afghans have lived with war for decades, so fatalism may explain their lack of pessimism.

Advertisement
You must be a registered user to comment.  Click here to register.  Already a user?  Click here to login.

Member Comments

Posted By: JustAJoe (November 12, 2009 at 4:41 PM)

Don't read too much into this and confuse "feel things are getting better" with becoming the people we want them to be. "Getting better" means something like  "hoping someday to have a paved road'

We went in with two goals - root out the terrorist radicals and bestow the gift of American style democracy. They are contradictory and mutually exclusive. If someone invaded us and tried to impose their values on us, what would happen?We wouldn't just abandon our values and accept theirs,  we would fight and become more radically American. That's what would happen here and what's happening there. The Afghans have their barbaric Islamic Courts, rule by tribal warlords, drug dealing  and terrible abuse of women. Why? Because they are Afghans and that is how they live and what they do. There is no sigh they are eager to change who they are, adopt our values  and become some sort of Americans.

The tribes in the cities and the tribes in the countryside have been fighting for control for hundreds of years, The current situation is consistent with this. We are trying to setup a central government administered from Kabul, we are in the cities and we are fighting the tribes in the countryside.

For the reasons I have said, we gave our military a flawed mission. Our military, being who they are, keeps coming up with plans to accomplish the mission, not always believing they will succeed, but doing their best

I am very pleased President Obama has shown the courage to reject these plans. Looking at the sham elections, he is questioning if the democracy we have tried to impose over eight years is taking or have we created a charade.

But the real question is when did Americans start dieing and going broke to force people in other countries to act like Americans. The answer is very recently and it is not too late to go back to a normal policy.


Posted By: hsr0601 (November 11, 2009 at 7:46 AM)

From My Viewpoint,  America Needs To Pursue Peace Deals With the Taliban.