Rana Foroohar
|
Apr 14, 2009 01:50 PM
Migrant workers are among the most vulnerable in any nation. There's been a lot of worry during this financial crisis that growing unemployment in the U.S., Europe and elsewhere would result in a wave of migrant job losses, forcing immigrants to return to their home countries (and back to even more precarious situations). That has a knock on economic effect, because in many poor countries, remittances, or money sent home from migrant workers, represents a major source of national income -- in Mexico, for example, remittances are the biggest contributor to the economy after oil revenues. And indeed, they are already falling -- Dilip Ratha, the lead economist at the World Bank, recently noted on his blog that remittances around the world will likely fall by 5 to 8 percent in 2009.
But a close read of Ratha's post indicates that the situation isn't as bleak as it might appear. For starters, net migration flows around the world are still up, ironically in part because migrants are scared to go home due to a rise in anti-immigration sentiment. As Hania Zlotnik, the director of the United Nation's Population Division told me last month, "They are afraid now that once they leave, they'll never be able to come back in." Since overall remittance payments depend on the absolute number of immigrants abroad, rather than just how many are entering new countries in a given year, there's a good chance that remittances will pick up in 2010, as the financial crisis (hopefully) eases.
What's more worrisome is the tightening of border controls in both the U.S and Europe, tougher entry requirements and the threat of labor protectionism implicit in both. This isn't just political, its very much an economic issue. As my colleague and fellow blogger Barrett Sheridan wrote in a Newsweek International piece recently, freer migration has the potential to contribute more to the global economy than freer trade. While completing the onerous Doha Round (stick with me here, we're almost done...) of trade negotiations would increase global GDP growth by only 0.04 percent, some economists believe that freer migration could add over one full percentage point to global growth. By allowing workers to go where they need to go to find jobs, we are actually helping create more work for everyone. Tell that to anybody who worries about migrants taking their jobs.